One rather surprising finding after Week 1 in Philadelphia was the spillover effect it had on my time in the Bay Area. I found that just paying attention to my “transit habits” altered them, at least a little.
All in all there were a number of unexpected similarities to the two areas in terms of transit. Some remarkable differences to be sure, but still not everything was as different as I previously thought.
I noticed that, while in the Bay Area, I began to organize my time differently so that I didn’t need to drive as much as usual. It took some planning, and clearly there were times when it was truly impossible to avoid driving, but not as much as I had thought in the past. One stunning contrast, though, was the difference in cost of public transit. During the second week I was there I needed to go from Berkeley to the city. Driving is always an option, but the cost of parking in the city is on par with New York in most places. So, I drove to the West Oakland BART station, parked my car there and took the train under the bay into downtown San Francisco.
But here’s the thing: parking there cost $6 a day – a steal by most standards to be sure. And then there is the cost of the trip to the city – about 3 bucks each way. So, that’s $12 a day just to avoid one of the world’s busiest bridges. Compare that to $18 or so a week for a transit pass in Philadelphia. By the second day…
And then there is the race thing. I spoke to one of my young Verger colleagues there, Franklin Hysten, about why there are no white folks on the buses in Oakland. Franklin deadpanned, Wow, I noticed that, too! During the conversation he was reminded of the scene in the movie, Crash, where one character says that the reason the bus windows are so big is so that the rich people can see all the poor people taking the bus. The only problem with that observation is that the train windows are fairly big as well. But still.
We also spoke about one big difference between SF and PHL transit-wise is that lots of white people take the bus in SF. We came to the obvious conclusion – white people take buses when other white people take buses. Very few middle-class while folks take the bus in Oakland, so very few middle class folks take the bus in Oakland. (This of course leads to the next questions: How much of this dynamic is a function of race, and how much is about class?)
Arriving back in Philadelphia last night I was aware of an amazing confluence of well-functioning systems. Yesterday morning I left the flat in Berkeley a bit after 10 am, walked through the Cal campus to the Downtown Berkeley BART station. I waited about 3 minutes for a train. Two stations later I transferred to a train headed to the city (it was waiting across the platform), and then at the southern end of the city I made a final transfer to a train to the airport (after a wait of less than ten minutes). I arrived at the airport in plenty of time, got through security and boarded the plane without any hassles. The plane had about forty passengers on board, so everyone had their own row.
We had a great tailwind, so we arrived in Philadelphia about forty-five minutes early (about 8:45pm). I walked to the train platform at the airport and got there a little before 9. The train to the city arrived right on time at 9:12pm, and got to 30th Street Station at 9:30. The local train arrived on the next platform on time at 9:40 and arrived at my station, Tulpehocken, at 9:57 on the dot – right on time. A three-minute walk later and I was opening my front door at 10pm.
It was all so effortless. I know that it is not like this all the time, but when it is, it is a delightful way to move my molecules around.
One other thing I noticed on the two trains from the airport - how different the ads are on the train as opposed to the buses. On the buses there are lots of ads about HIV testing and fair housing, and ads for immigration lawyers. On both trains, though, I saw this ad from The Philadelphia Foundation:
If Warren Buffet
needs some help
giving away his money,
maybe you do, too.
On the 23 Bus there was this ad from the decidedly not not-for-profit, First National Fund:
CASH BY PHONE
$100 - $500
MAKE ONE CALL
You’ll get the cash you need
TODAY
If The Philadelphia Foundation ad ever appears on the #23 Bus line, then maybe we will be getting somewhere with Transit Publicus.